The Impact of Competition Law on Exclusive Lease Agreements in South Africa

In South Africa, the practice of including exclusivity provisions in long-term lease agreements between property developers and supermarkets has recently come under scrutiny. The Competition Commission's investigation into these practices has led to significant changes, particularly impacting the grocery retail sector.

Background: Exclusive Lease Agreements and the Grocery Retail Market Inquiry (GRMI)

The GRMI Report

• Findings: The report, released in November 2019, found that exclusivity provisions in lease agreements limited consumer choice and stifled innovation in the grocery retail sector.

• Conclusion: The report argued that there was no substantial justification for continuing these long-term exclusive lease agreements unfettered.

Landmark Decision: The Case of Shoprite Checkers

Consent Agreement with the Competition Commission

• Outcome: On October 13, 2020, the Competition Tribunal confirmed an order based on a consent agreement between the Competition Commission and Shoprite Checkers (Pty) Ltd.

• Agreement Terms: Shoprite agreed to cease enforcing exclusivity provisions against small, medium, and micro enterprises (SMMEs) and speciality stores like butcheries and bakeries.

Phased Implementation

• Non-Urban Areas: Immediate prohibition on exclusivity enforcement in non-urban areas, including townships and rural areas.

• Urban Areas: A five-year grace period for urban Shoprite stores to phase out exclusivity provisions against other supermarket chains.

Implications for the Grocery Retail Sector

This ruling prevents Shoprite from excluding competition, such as smaller suppliers, from shopping centers where they operate. This decision paves the way for these suppliers to access leasing space in shopping centers, enhancing competition and consumer choice.

Legal Considerations in Contract Drafting

This case underscores the importance of adhering to competition laws when drafting and entering into contracts. Anti-competitive practices can result in significant legal and financial consequences.

Our Legal Services

Our law firm specializes in providing guidance on competition law and contract drafting. We help clients navigate these complex legal landscapes, ensuring compliance and protecting their interests.

Conclusion

The Shoprite case marks a pivotal moment in South African competition law, with far-reaching effects on the grocery retail industry. Businesses must be vigilant in their contractual practices to avoid anti-competitive pitfalls. For legal advice on competition law, exclusive lease agreements, or contract drafting, please contact our law firm. Our team of experts is ready to assist you with your legal needs.