Sale of Shares vs. Subscription of Shares in South Africa: Understanding the Key Differences

When it comes to acquiring ownership in a South African company, two common methods are the sale of shares and the subscription of shares. Each method has its own implications and considerations. In this article, we will explore the differences between a sale of shares and a subscription of shares in South Africa, providing valuable insights for individuals and businesses seeking clarity on these concepts.

Understanding the Basics: Sale of Shares

The sale of shares involves the transfer of existing shares from one shareholder to another. In this scenario, the shares being sold already exist and are owned by the seller. The buyer acquires the shares by purchasing them directly from the existing shareholder, resulting in a change of ownership.

Understanding the Basics: Subscription of Shares

On the other hand, a subscription of shares refers to the process of issuing new shares to individuals or entities who wish to become shareholders. In this case, the company offers shares for purchase to potential shareholders who subscribe to them. The company creates and issues new shares, increasing its share capital and bringing in new owners.

Legal Implications and Procedures for the Sale of Shares

In South Africa, the sale of shares involves a transfer of ownership without any impact on the company's share capital. The process typically requires:

• Negotiating and Agreeing on Terms: The buyer and seller negotiate the terms of the sale, including the purchase price, conditions, and warranties.

• Drafting a Share Sale Agreement: Once the terms are agreed upon, a share sale agreement is drafted to formalize the transaction. This document outlines the rights and obligations of both parties and includes provisions related to warranties, representations, and indemnities.

• Transfer of Ownership: To transfer the shares, the parties must execute the necessary documentation, such as a share transfer form. The company's share register is updated to reflect the change in ownership.

Legal Implications and Procedures for the Subscription of Shares

When subscribing to shares in South Africa, there are specific legal procedures to follow:

• Offer and Acceptance: The company makes an offer to potential shareholders, inviting them to subscribe to new shares. The interested parties accept the offer and agree to purchase the shares at the specified price.

• Memorandum of Incorporation (MOI) and Shareholders' Agreement: The MOI is amended to include the details of the new shares being issued. A shareholders' agreement may also be drafted to define the rights and obligations of the new shareholders.

• Issue of Shares: The company issues the new shares to the subscribing shareholders, resulting in an increase in the company's share capital. The shares are typically paid for in cash or through other agreed-upon methods.

Considerations for Buyers and Sellers

• Control and Voting Rights: In a sale of shares, the buyer acquires the existing shares along with the associated voting rights. In a subscription of shares, the buyer becomes a new shareholder and may or may not have immediate control or voting rights, depending on the terms of the subscription.

• Dilution and Capitalization: When new shares are issued through a subscription, existing shareholders may experience dilution of their ownership percentage. In a sale of shares, there is no dilution since the shares already exist.

• Due Diligence: Buyers should conduct due diligence on the company's financials, legal compliance, and other relevant aspects before purchasing existing shares. Subscribers should assess the company's potential for growth and future prospects before subscribing to new shares.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between the sale of shares and the subscription of shares in South Africa is crucial for individuals and businesses entering into ownership transactions. By grasping the legal implications, procedures, and considerations associated with each method, parties can make informed decisions. Optimizing this article with SEO techniques ensures that it reaches a wider audience seeking clarity on the topic of share transactions in South Africa.

If you would like to find out more, contact our offices today to schedule a consultation with one of our specialist corporate law attorneys.